Ken Lyen's Home
About
Ken's Links
Hakkas
London Revisited 2000
Letter from London 2006
Singapore Musical Theatre
Making the Grade
Exodus
Other
Writing Musicals
Musicals from Movies
Fred Ebb
The Story of Chess
Mama Mia
Bad Vibrations
Chestnuts 2003
Chestnuts 2004
Chestnuts 2005
Incubating New Musicals
List of Musicals on Film
Is Musical Theatre Dead?
Is Classical Music Dead?
Is Poetry Dead?
Why Read Poetry?
Etymology
New Words
Cull
Nothing's Wrong
Hippie Dictionary
Singlish Dictionary
Blog Dictionary
Best of the Best
English Spoke
Bilingualism
Reading in Decline
Too Many Books
Magic of Reading
Pablo Neruda
Graphic Novels
Writers Bar
Lost For Words
Encyclopedia Wars
Library in Cyberspace
The Bridge
Growing A Film Industry
Critics
Great Levellers
Rote Rites and Rongs
Beautiful Minds
Intelligence
Creativity
Create Talented Individuals?
Rise of the Creative Class
Perchance to Dream
Children's EQ
Gifted Education
Gifted Children
Mozart Effect
Confucius and Multiple Intelligences
Predicting Your Future
Mistyping Personality
Messy Homes
Does Age Matter?
Too Young for Philosophy?
Philosopher for Hire
Deconstructing Derrida
University Quotas
Ranking Universities
University Ranking Continued
The Future of Universities
If Thine Eye Offends Thee
If It Ain't Broke
New Exams for Old!
Too Many Test
The Sincerest Form of Flattery
Childhood Memories
Voluntarism
Signs of Success
Follow Your Dreams
First Impressions
Handphone Etiquette
Handphones Silenced
Nanotechnology
Apple Of My i
Sex and the Media
The Greeks
Geographic Clangers
Domino Theory
Hello Kitty
Heels on Wheels
What a Racket!
Potty Training
Skip to the Loo
Corporal Punishment
Is Modern Art Rubbish?
Mona Lisa Grins
Vermeer
Sunday in the Park
Vision and Art
Fake
Gmail
Spam Glorious Spam!
Humble Pie
Sour Grapes?
Murphy's Law Calculator
Perfect Search
False Logic
Noah's Ark
Who Discovered America?
Palaces of Dictators
Queues
Backup
Joys of Stress
Games Academics Play
Virtual Reality Treatmemt
Autism
Autistic Underconnectivity
Asperger Syndrome
Pay Attention!
Attention Deficit
Dyslexia
Speech Delay
Almost Normal
Prozac Nation
Gilles de la Tourette
Singapore Medicine
Ignorance
Virtual Dissection
War Against Malaria
Into the Frying Pan
Back to Methuselah
Poetic Medicine
Cigarettes
Far Eastern Economic Review
History of the Singapore Musical
My Research
Singapore Idle
Best Countries
Brain Drain
Greatest Happiness
Remaking Singapore
Singapore Nobel Prize
Singapore MRT Map
National Day
Caste System
Doctors' Fees
Leadership and Teambuilding
Doctor Do-Much
Interview
Play it Again, Doc
A Dose of Music
Prescription for the Heart
Multiple Personality
Sayang
Fly By Night
Muggle
Rape of Nanking
Iris Chang
Anne Frank
Angela's Ashes
The Notebook
Hollywood Insider
Fahrenheit 9/11 Pirates
The Front
The Barbarian Invasions
Les Choristes
The Return
Road Home
Shower
2046
Farewell My Concubine
So You Want to be a Nurse
Roulette
Fences
School House Rockz
Makan Place
e-mail me

Virtual Dissection


 

Virtual Dissection

by Kenneth Lyen

I studied biology at school and dissected frogs, dogfish, earthworms, rats and cockroaches. The ethics of dissecting a life never entered my mind. This is a controversial area, and will continue to be debated well into the future.

When the computer programme for dissecting a virtual frog became available, I tried it out, but realised that it was a totally different experience from dissecting the real thing.

Computer simulation programmes are becoming increasingly sophisticated, and reality is being recreated more accurately. For example, Microsoft’s Flight Simulator is a popular programme that gives you the feel of flying a small aircraft. I've tried it, but unfortunately my plane always crashed, which is probably why I did not choose to be an airline pilot. However, flight training schools use an advanced flight simulation programme to teach their pilots to fly. Go to any arcade and you can drive a racing car or a motorcycle, and even play virtual tennis. The regular army uses war games to battle it out with virtual enemies. There are stocks and shares programmes that allow you to use real data from the bourses. There is even a medical programme called ER, about handling patients in the emergency room, and luckily I fared a bit better with this, compared to flight simulation.

Recently, in Virginia USA, a seventh grade student objected to dissecting a preserved frog. Her teacher allowed her to dissect a virtual frog on the computer. This year, the Singapore Medical School has discontinued the age-old practice of dissecting human cadavers. Instead, all medical students have to dissect a virtual body on a computer.

The advantages of dissecting a virtual frog or a human are obvious. There is no need to obtain the real thing. It is cleaner, and if you make a mistake in your dissection, you can do it again. Furthermore, it is far easier to dissect on the computer than in real life.

The problem with dissecting the real thing is that the preservative alters the colour and textures, so that it is not really the "real thing" anyway. On the other hand, the three-dimensional topology of the real thing is something that a computer cannot simulate.

The fundamental question is whether or not you will become a better biologist or doctor if you have handled real materials. Probably not. However it can be argued that practitioners should be closer to their materials so as to gain a better feel for it. There is a sense of unreality when doing a virtual dissection.

Which technique is better for training?

In the case of medicine, dissection is probably best carried out on a living patient during a surgical operation. There is no substitute for this. I would not like to be operated by a surgeon whose only training is on a computer simulation programme. Come to think of it, I would not like to be operated by a student who is doing his or her very first case!